Sunday, March 4, 2012

...the predator-prey model

By kay.e.strong


On 16 February the Congressional Budget Office (CBO) released its report Understanding and Responding to Persistently High Unemployment.

The CBO cites the current period as the longest stretch of high unemployment since the Great Depression with the unemployment in excess of eight (8) percent since February 2009 and their projection is for it to remain above 8 percent until 2014.  Be reminded that the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), the official dater of turning points in the economy, declared June 2009 as the trough of the last business cycle. [http://www.nber.org/cycles/cyclesmain.html]  Now three years into the expansionary phase of current business cycle, the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in the January 2012 an unemployment rate of 8.3 percent (or, 12.7 million individuals).  And this number excludes a persistent 2.8 million individuals identified as marginally attached (willing-able-looked for a job but stopped looking in a 4-week interval) to the labor market.

In the short term the CBO report attributes the persistence of high unemployment to slack demand for goods and services.  Not surprisingly, unemployment and demand are a coupled system. Unemployment rises when business inventory exceeds desired levels due to insufficient demand. The loss of income associated with unemployment widens the gap between business inventory and insufficient demand. In many ways, the dynamics of unemployment-demand replicate the dynamics of competition in biological systems.  With little effort we can juxtapose the unemployment-demand story in to the classic predator-prey model—where businesses are likened to predators and demand, the prey.

In this story the prey (demand) has unlimited food supply.  The size of the predator population (businesses) depends on the size of the prey population (demand).  Rate of change in a population (businesses or demand) is proportional to its size.  The external environment does not shift in favor one species (businesses or demand) and adaptation is sufficiently slow.  

Over time predators (businesses) thrive in an environment with plenty of prey (demand).  Growth in the predator population is, ultimately, checked when its growth outstrips food supply, the prey.  Thereafter, the predator population (businesses) goes into decline. As one might expect a predator-prey system is inherently self-annihilating without some outside intervention. Intervention in the biological system, say, the reintroduction of prey, allows for a rebound—but a rebound out-of-synch with predators.

O.K, besides being a nice story, what conclusion(s) might one draw from this exercise?

The most obvious: introduction of more predators into the environment is conclusively NOT the solution!

Yet, time again, most political prescriptions for our economic predator-prey problem focus exclusively on the predator (businesses) and, only begrudgingly, on the prey (demand). 

In January the Bureau of Labor Statistics reported that “[t]he number of long-term unemployed (those jobless for 27 weeks or more) was little changed at 5.5 million down slightly from January 2011 (6.2 million) and accounted for 42.9 percent of the unemployed.” This number, however, excludes 2.8 million individuals identified as marginally attached to the labor market. January-to-January numbers showed a reduction in the overall participation rate of the civilian non-institutional population from 64.2% (2011) to 63.7% (2012).  Between December and January the labor market absorbed 4.5 million workers, while shedding 7.3 million.

Despite the evidence, OpenCongress reports a new deal in the works concerning the prey:

  • Assume the lack of food on the table-roof over head is insufficient motivation for the unemployed to search for jobs that don’t exist! Prescription: shrink the maximum length of unemployment benefits to 63 week.
  • Assume drugs are the primary cause of unemployment. Prescription: beneficiaries subject to drug testing.
  • Assume budgetary funding is likely tied to cuts in other parts of the social safety net. Prescription: mandatory “reemployment assessment” and training for long-term unemployed.
  • Assume sufficient numbers of unemployed have long since been “deleveraged” of homes, therefore, highly mobile. Prescription: mandate “national job search requirements.”
Seriously, how does killing off the prey (demand) not hasten the demise of the predator (businesses)!  

Alternatively, the CBO ran an analysis of tax-spending policies designed to “reintroduce prey,” allowing for a rebound over the next two years.  CBO concluded that the largest increases in employment per dollar of budgetary cost would be produced by two measures:
  • Reducing the marginal cost to businesses of adding employees and
  • Targeting people most likely to spend the additional income (generally, people with lower income).
Long term (structural) unemployment is a bit trickier to address.  CBO advocates policies designed to eliminate the mismatches between employers' needs and workers' skills through training programs. The mismatch between job locations and potential workers will require a stronger housing market or relocation-style transition programs. Likewise, employers will require “re-education” to mitigate the social sigma associated with hiring the unemployed. Poaching employees in no way lessens our national unemployment problem.

Nature has been engaged in the predator-prey dance for eons.  Let’s swallow our pride and follow her lead on this one!

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Sunday, February 26, 2012

…not an Industrial Nation

By kay.e.strong

In January President Obama touted that an economic recovery “begins with American manufacturing.”

The Brookings report: Why Does Manufacturing Matter? Which Manufacturing Matters?, opined “[p]ublic policy is needed to help strengthen manufacturing and prompt a high-wage, innovative, export-intensive, and environmentally sustainable manufacturing base.”

I just don’t get it.  Why are we so obsessed with looking backward to the future?

The United States is no more an industrial nation now than it is an agricultural nation.  Before the turn of the 20th century, a quarter of the American population was down on the farm.  Now, maybe, 3% , that is, three percent of the population is engaged in plowing-discing-dragging-seeding American fields, raising livestock and caring for fruit and vegetable plants. And three percent is sufficient to put foodstuff on the tables of Americans and have plenty to make the US a net exporter of food!  America’s agricultural sector exhibits high productivity!  Similarly, in its heyday, the manufacturing sector was the backbone of the American economy.  Its relative size of employment today stands shy of 9%, down from 21% in the 1980s. Assuming 150 million workers in the labor force, 3 percent devoted to agriculture, 9 percent to manufacturing, what are all the rest of us doing?  Ah, providing services!  Yup, 87% of American workers are employed in the service economy…and expenditure on services accounted for $7 of our $15 billion GDP in 2011…making the U.S. a Service Nation!

Some lament the loss of high-wage jobs as our manufacturing sector has downsized. What they really miss are the high-paying jobs for low skill/ low educated workers.  But that train ride is over!  As one would expect, comparative advantage has kicked in.  Low-skill manufacturing jobs have migrated to mass-production, low cost facilities abroad.  The world benefits by shrinking deadweight loss from production inefficiency.  Now, about that “high-wage” thing.  Every worker’s pay is based on his marginal revenue product, translated: your wage is equal to your added contribution to company revenue.  The more productive you are, the more you add to revenue.  The US has the unique advantage of mixing workers with high levels of capital—the secret sauce of high-wages in manufacturing today.  On the downside, though, more capital per worker means the manufacturing sector is demanding more skilled workers.  Higher education and higher skills go hand-in-hand with higher wages in both manufacturing and service sectors.  Want high wage?  Get skilled!

The Brookings report argues that manufacturing drives innovation.  I rather believe that innovation hubs like Bell Labs (NJ) or Silicon Valley (CA) drive revenue streams for  manufacturing.   Innovation hubs bring “thinkers and tinkers” together under the same roof.  Closer the proximity, the denser the body count of would-be innovators, the higher the probability of new streams of production for manufacturing.  Lesson: pitch federal dollars toward research and development hives not solo-operations.  Cultivate the innovation ecology of communities.  Strengthen fast pitch innovation techniques such as crowd-sourcing, open-source access and redistribution and social entrepreneurship.  Unharnessed ideas propagate faster.

Another claim of the Brookings report asserts that “[m]anufacturing can make a major contribution to reducing the nation’s trade deficit.”  As can a drop in the relative value of the dollar or a reduction in reliance on imported petroleum products!   As for the export of manufactured goods, specifically, “[o]nly about 4% of manufacturing firms in the U.S. exported in 2000 and 96% of all U.S. exports are sold by just 10% of this already small set of firms.” That 10% would be the industries of chemicals, transportation equipment, computers and electronic products, and machinery.  Clearly then, these industries not manufacturing broadly stand to benefit disproportionately by export push policies. [http://www.brookings.edu/opinions/2012/0220_manufacturing_klein.aspx]

Nostalgia makes for great literature but not a great economy.  We are passed our Industrial Nation prime and in the youthful bloom of our Service Nation present.  Let’s get on with making policy aligned with reality!

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Sunday, February 19, 2012

… illiteracy is killing the economy

By kay.e.strong

...that is, economic illiteracy!  If ever you were looking for a leverage point to improve the economy, then bagging bad politics (along with the politicians) would do it! 

“The polarized rhetoric of the 2012 election cycle presents voters with a false choice of whether the government can create jobs or should just get out of the way.” (NYT: How Not to Revive an Economy by Michael Grabell, 11 Feb 2012)

Amen to that!

Politic is not economics.  Their goals differ.  Politics is and has always been about maximizing the voice of the few at the expense of the majority. And I get it.  The voice of a minority is important.  It rounds out national discussion by offering a counter perspective that tempers the lunacy of the majority.  What if the minority voices had been heard, would the moral depravity of Hitler’s regime have reached 6 million Jewish lives?  

On the other hand, economics is about maximizing the well-being of the majority at the expense of the minority. This is where politics steps into to mitigate minority losses. In Measuring the Costs of Protection in the United States, Hufbauer and Elliot report: Still, the annual consumer costs per American job "saved" by "special" protection range from $100,000 to over $1 million and average $170,000. Consumers thus pay over six times the average annual compensation of manufacturing workers to preserve each job. In terms of net national welfare, the cost per protected job is about $54,000.

Political rhetoric kills.  Government and markets are the twin pillars of a healthy economy.  Good governance matters!  It explains large differences in the performance of economies. The nation of Zimbabwe celebrated the December to January drop in inflation from 4.9% to 4.3%.  This is a huge deal given that Zimbabwe has experienced inflation rates as high as 11.2 million percent!  Yes, 11.2 million percent requiring a single Zimbabwe dollar denominated as 1 trillion ZWR!  The Japanese, on the other hand, struggle with the opposite problem.  Deflation, negative growth rates of prices levels, has plagued the Japanese for more than a decade making it nearly impossible to rev the economic engine.  

Unemployment-wise, the rate in the troubled euro zone stood at 10.3% comparable to the US in October.  The German economy faired better than average with rate of 5.5%. The Greek economy has reached +18% with more austerity measures in the works. Throughout the eurozone youth unemployment rates range from 24% (France), 45% (Greece) to 49% (Spain). Athenian youth recently took to the streets in a “burn, baby, burn” rampage reminiscent of Detroit riots of the 1960s.  In Japan, employment figures conceal the second-class status of Japanese youth where 45% hold irregular jobs, up from 17.2 percent in 1988 and double the rate of older workers.

Rather than pitting government against the market, “[t]he real debate should be about which policies work and which don’t.” Score, Mr. Grabell, two points on this pop quiz!  So what doesn’t work:  more austerity on top of austerity [think, Greece], stimulus money directed at deep infrastructural projects like roads [think, US], or institutional policies such as underfunded pension plans which discourages older worker turnover [think, Japan].

Economic growth is a long-run phenomenon; unemployment is a by-product of short run economic fluctuations. What we need is a Stimulus 2.0 package that marries both ends of the stick, simultaneously. That is, policies that lay the ground work for long-run growth, while stimulating short-run demand. So here’s my top economic policy picks.

1. Reinvest in Americans not America.  Make post-secondary education affordable by subsidizing its cost for any American willing to take on the challenge…and political whiners get a passport free-of-charge out of the country!  

2. Eliminate the outrageous 8.5% interest rate being charged to American youths who have invested in higher education on their own dime.  For heaven-sakes, the fed funds rate is only 0.25% on a bad day! Redirect those “shovel ready” dollars from roads to absorbing interest payments for America's future workers!

3. Open the doors to educated youth worldwide to seek “unemployment refugee” status in the US. Immigration as a trigger for economic growth is well-documented. The Kauffman Foundation characterizes foreign-born entrepreneurs as an underestimated American resource!  The report states that “… in a quarter of the U.S. science and technology companies founded from 1995 to 2005, the chief executive or lead technologist was foreign-born. In 2005, these companies generated $52 billion in revenue and employed 450,000 workers.” Tell me, we couldn't use the brain-power! [Source: http://www.kauffman.org/entrepreneurship/foreign-born-entrepreneurs.aspx ]

Mr. Grabell—who’s probably neither an economist nor a politician—got it right: “… there are areas where the government should get out of the away, by clearing bureaucratic hurdles. But it’s equally important for politics to get out of the way of smart government policies....”.

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Monday, February 6, 2012

Whose Recession?

By Lewis Sage


Financial pundits define a recession as two consecutive quarters of decline in real GDP.  But as the old joke goes, “When your neighbor loses his job it’s a recession; when you lose your job, it’s a depression.”  The National Bureau of Economic Research – NBER to the cognoscenti – has a more nuanced analysis based on their criterion of “a significant decline in activity”.
In their judgment, The Great Recession, measured from peak to trough, began in December 2007 and ended in June 2009, real growth in the second quarter of 2008 notwithstanding.  The starting date is pretty easy to agree with: the unemployment rate rose from 4.7% to 5.0% in December of 2007; payroll employment peaked in January; and real GDP fell in the first quarter of 2008.  But the end date of June 2009 is harder to swallow.
Payroll employment declined every month from February 2008 through September 2010, fully five quarters after the NBER terminal date.  True, the rate of job loss was small compared to 2008:IV and 2009:I, but loss is loss.  Unemployment data tells a similar story, peaking at 10.0% in October 2009 and then oscillating from 9.7% to 9.9% for the next six months before beginning a slow decline in May 2010.  It’s become common wisdom that employment lags GDP recovery, but I would argue that the persistence of unemployment’s misery has become so great as to be disconnected from the rise and fall of the business cycle.
Let me suggest a more intuitive definition of an economic slack period: an interval in which the unemployment rate is at least 25% higher than its long-run equilibrium level.  In my lifetime, the average monthly unemployment rate in the US has been 5.8%, placing my arbitrary threshold of labor misery at about 7.25%.
So let’s see how the 7.25% solution compares to business recessions since 1970.
Slack Labor Market Interval
12-1974 to 06-1977             (NBER measure ~ no recession)
05-1980 to 07-1985             (NBER measure ~ 1980:II-III, 1981:IV-1982:I)
12-1991 to 01-1993             (NBER measure ~ no recession)
12-2008 to present               (NBER measure ~ 2008:I-2009:II)
By the NBER measure, we have been in recession less than 8% of the time since 1970; by the threshold measure, it’s almost 29% of the time.  If you’re a college graduate (unemployment rate 4.2%), you’re more likely to think the recession has been over for a while; if you never graduated high school, (unemployment rate 13.1%), the recession may seem permanent.



Dr. Lewis C. Sage (AB Kenyon, PhD U. Maryland) likes intersections. Since 1991, he has taught Law and Economics, Mathematical Economics, and the Economics of Healthcare. A former Fulbright Fellow (Bulgaria 1995-6), he teaches an interdisciplinary Honors seminar, Enduring Questions, and is studying strategy in the NFL draft with faculty and students in Sport Management and Psychology. E-mail: lsage@bw.edu

…Greek inclusion

By kay.e.strong

Reuters ran Analysis: Euro zone strugglers lack innovate knack ahead of today’s Greek debt deadline (6 Feb).

The 911 version:  Using R&D expenditure and patent filings per million inhabitants as proxies for innovative capacity, the writer concludes Greek ranks dead last relative to fellow Euro zone nations.  As an innovation laggard Greece is seen lacking in ability to spawn growth sufficient to sustain their debt load.  Andrew Wyckoff, director of an OECD think tank, catalogs software, human capital development in knowledge-intensive sectors, intellectual property and organizational know-how of companies as complementary elements of innovations.  Overhauling the underlying Greek business environment to enhance its international competitiveness is the solution of choice with government directing the process through business-friendly policy changes.

In Adam Smith’s story On the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations the secret of wealth generation revolved around the division of labor with specialization, learning by repetitive doing, productivity, and competition playing the lead character roles in the story.

But a story with a new twist challenges conventional wisdom. Research out of Harvard’s Center for International Development argues that the richest countries are those with the most complex economies—and actually produce the greatest diversity of goods (Harvard Magazine. Complexity and the Wealth of Nations). Using network science, the researchers have complied their findings in The Atlas of Economic Complexity: Mapping Paths to Prosperity < http://atlas.media.mit.edu/ >.

The social accumulation of productive knowledge and its recombination into a more diverse and sophisticated variety of products is the main ingredient for growing prosperity. The researchers, Richardo Hausmann and Cesar Hidalgo argue that accomplishments of the past two centuries are a product of our getting smarter—not individually, but collectively. 

“Modern societies can amass large amounts of productive knowledge because they distribute bits and pieces of it among its many members. But to make use of it, this knowledge has to be put back together through organizations and markets. Thus, individual specialization begets diversity at the national and global level. Our most prosperous modern societies are wiser, not because their citizens are individually brilliant, but because these societies hold a diversity of knowhow and because they are able to recombine it to create a larger variety of smarter and better products.”

The income gap between nations is expressed as a gap in social accumulation of productive knowledge and evidence by the differences in the product space of nations. Products are emblematic of the level of productive knowledge. Where the divergence between the total amount of knowledge embedded in society and that held by each member of society is narrow, economic complexity is low as is living standards.

“The secret to modernity is that we collectively use large volumes of knowledge (in producing products), while each one of us holds only a few bits of it. Society functions because its members form webs that allow them to specialize and share their knowledge with others.”

Markets and organizations are nodes in those webs making us collectively wiser.

Accumulating productive knowledge is about more than book smarts—explicit knowledge. It involves growing tacit knowledge through deep specialization (personbytes) and modularized chunking at the individual and organizational level and through our networks of organizations.

Doing so, complexifies the economy.  A nation’s mix of productive output reflects its level of economic complexity.  Nations make products on par with their accumulated social productive knowledge space.  

“Complex economies are those that can weave vast quantities of relevant knowledge together, across large networks of people, to generate a diverse mix of knowledge-intensive products. Simpler economies, in contrast, have a narrow base of productive knowledge and produce fewer and simpler products, which require smaller webs of interaction. Because individuals are limited in what they know, the only way societies can expand their knowledge base is by facilitating the interaction of individuals in increasingly complex webs of organizations and markets. Increased economic complexity is necessary for a society to be able to hold and use a larger amount of productive knowledge, and we can measure it from the mix of products that countries are able to make.”

Viewed from this perspective, the Greeks have a scaffolding problem.  For prosperity-sake they need to reach deeper into their product space but lack the requisite match in the patterns of interaction inside their organizations and own society. Drawing them deeper into the complex webs of organizations and markets of more prosperous neighbors is a practical means to overcome the scaffold problem for nations like Greece.  Learning by interacting holds more promise than a sterile bailout package.

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Sunday, February 5, 2012

…rethinking the wealth of nations

By kay.e.strong

This semester I’m diligently working at integrating new thinking into my macro principles course. My objective is to better match content with the current realities of the world we inhabit. I’m far from alone in believing that the field of economics needs an enema! I have an ally in the Institute for New Thinking (INET) < http://ineteconomics.org/ >.  The INET sprang from the failings of traditional economics during the great Global Meltdown—not unlike Keynesian economics following the 1930s debacle of classical economics.  The push for new economic thinking has one advantage British economist J. M. Keynes did not have; INET, a diverse global collaborative of thousands of trained economists, including Nobel Prize winners and others—teachers and students—“attracted by a promise of a free and open economic discourse.”  INET’s mission is “to nurture a global community of next-generation economic leaders, to provoke new economic thinking and to inspire the economics profession to engage the challenges of the 21st century.”

Just as Occupy Wall Street broached the topics of greed, economic exclusion and failed policies, INET is likewise destine to shake up traditional economic thinking and its benefactors.

For an illustration, let’s crack open Adam Smith’s tome, The Wealth of Nations, the cornerstone of economics.

Many are familiar with this oft quoted passage:

"It is not from the benevolence of the butcher, the brewer, or the baker, that we expect our dinner, but from their regard to their own self-interest. We address ourselves, not to their humanity but to their self-love, and never talk to them of our own necessities but of their advantages."

A brick in the foundation of laissez-faire economic policy which free marketers worship is typically traced back to this passage. Others tag the passage as the seed of the invisible hand metaphor attributed to Smith.
The invisible hand represents the undirected coordinating role that the price mechanism performs in guiding economic activity to its natural conclusion. The mantra of the invisible hand runs interference for all kinds of supposed ills such as government help which is likened to freshly chewed bubblicious lying on a hot sidewalk.
 
Traditional economics focuses on the efficiency story of economics.  Efficiency is about cultivating the optimal competitive environment to insure highest possible production from supposed scarce resources.  Production effects are divorced from distributional effects. And Adam Smith has become a bastion for all beneficiaries of traditional economic thinkers advocating a hands-off policy role for government.

But new economic thinking is emerging. The new story challenges traditional rhetoric.  The new story portrays markets and economies as directed networks.  This is the complexity story—process rather than the state of competition is at its heart. The complexity story is based on a dynamic framework involving evolutionary change overtime that is not directly controlled or controllable—where economic forces interacting with and reacting to social, political, technological, and environmental forces create outcomes. Some desirable—others not quite so.  

The metaphor of the invisible hand is given a makeover in the complexity story.   Here the invisible hand stands for the idea of self-organization in which the potential “chaos” of seven billion individuals unfolds into an elegant complex structure of order that fits together—with sustainability its innate goal.

In the complexity story markets are social constructs, that is, markets could not have existed had we not collectively created them.  We created them—we can uncreate them, too!  Markets are not sacred cows—have at that bubblicious gum.

The complexity story acknowledges that we have collective moods.  Market volatility, business cycles, economic growth, inflation, technological and institutional innovation are macro outcomes of our collective psyche at work. Old equations don’t add up in the new thinking of economics. You plus me makes three. Old policy formulae are the bubblicious gumming up the works of the market and economy.

New economic thinking advocates a new role for government. 

“The common finding that economic structures can crystallize around small events and lock in is beginning to change policy…toward awareness that governments should avoid both extremes of coercing a desired outcome or keeping strict hands off, and instead seek to push the system gently toward favored structures that can grow and emerge naturally. Not a heavy handed, not an invisible hand, but a nudging hand.” –Brian Arthur, Santa Fe Institute (Complexity and the Economy. 1999:4)

I sense that one day all this new thinking will seem like old hat!

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Friday, February 3, 2012

...counterpoint

By kay.e.strong
 
“Nothing is so hard for those who abound in riches as to conceive how others can be in want.”—Jonathan Swift

p.s. for mitt

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Sunday, January 29, 2012

…life emulating sy-fy


By kay.e.strong

Syfy is often a bell-weather of the future—a point I like to make when talking with young people who are interested in the possibilities of the future.   Take for example, the 1950 movie Destination Moon, a sy-fy film focused on realistically detailing such a trip.  What makes this film all the more intriguing is that it appeared seven years before Sputnik’s launch!  And beyond that, Sergei Korolev would not make his proposal for an orbiting satellite to the Soviet Ministry of Defense until 1954.  The film posited as futuristic: realistic spaceflight, commercial interest in space and nuke-powered rockets.

Likewise, elements suggestive of today’s reality television first popped in sy-fy. Ray Bradbury’s 1953 novel Fahrenheit 451 portrayed live audience participation programming. The Running Man (1987), a loose rendition of Stephen King’s dystopian novel, is a television show about criminals who are released to out run publically-sanctioned professional killers. Twelve years later (1998) the entire life of an insurance salesman aired as The Truman Show.  Reality TV exploded…Big Brother, Survivor, American Idol...

As a genre reality television supposedly captures unscripted situations featuring ordinary people jockeying for the public’s eye.  It exploits sensationalism, or better, a highly-modified form of reality, to attract viewership and generate sponsorship.  Story editors coach participants into staging the desired illusion of reality. When that fails, post-production editing kicks in, gleaning the choicest event, the optimal word, the most suggestive expression.  By mismatching audio and video from different footages of film, an altered chronology is proffered as reality.    

If you have been alert, you’ve probably figured out that I’m no longer wandering the world of science fiction but rather life itself. Specifically, that pseudo-reality drama called American politics in which life emulates science fiction emulating life!

Take 1:  Romney’s campaign pounces on Gingrich with a hashtag, “#grandiosenewt” that runs a news cycle ridiculing Gingrich. If sensationalizing minutiae is the goal, then Twitter is an elegant pimping tool for retail politics.

Take 2: Gingrich’s one-minute post-production video haranguing Romney on dishonesty drew an immediate disclaimer from Huckabee.

“Any use of an out-of-context quote from the Republican presidential primary four years ago in a political ad to advocate for the election or defeat of another candidate is not authorized, approved, or known in advance by me.”

I never liked Reality TV.  I like reality TV politics even less.  Why?  Maybe, because it hits too close to the truth about how shallow the American psyche really is. And, sadly,  no matter how many times I punch the “off” on my reality remote it refuses to shutdown. So I'm locked into a neverending loop of life emulating the worst of sy-fy!

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Sunday, January 22, 2012

…the power of connection

By kay.e.strong

Much attention last week focused on the Internet Blackout, a showdown—somewhat reminiscent of the gun-slinging old Wild West—that pitted staid power-bases against an interwoven network of upstarts scattered around the globe. While designed to flex muscle over the control, distribution and access of bytes and bites, the take away is more portentous.

CBS reported: “On Jan. 18 websites like Wikipedia and Reddit staged a blackout of their sites to protest Stop Online Piracy Act (SOPA) and Protect IP Act (PIPA). Google joined the protest by blacking out their famous logo for a day. A count by the organization Fight for the Future placed the number of sites participating at 115,000.”

In perspective, the outcome fostered by 115,000 sites is a pale blush of the potential power of 582,716,657 connected sites acting in unison (January 2012 Web Server Survey - Netcraft.com).

Bill sponsor Senate Majority Leader Reid backed down whining that the twin evils of counterfeiting and piracy cost the American economy billions of dollars and thousands of jobs annually.  On the flip-side, however, downloading free media content from the Internet saves American consumers billions of dollars annually, supports alternative expenditures, stirs the pot of innovation and spawns jobs in imitation industries.

The idea of protecting intellectual property is really about protecting privilege—the privilege of money and power.  Money and power move lockstep in an amplifying feedback loop.  Money begets power which begets money which begets… bottom line:  Own the rules, own the game!
Money buys a seat at the table at which the rules are written.

The concept of intellectual property rights is antiquated—a throwback to despotic rulers positing a royal right to grant monopoly privileges.   In this country IPRs are neatly package into the “lone cowboy” series, epitomizing the ideals of self-fulfillment and self-reliance. Rugged individualism glorified and reward.

But nothing could be farther from the truth. Just as spectacularly beautiful coral reefs are built from the dead skeletons of many generations of coral polyps, so are ideas.  It was Bernard of Chartes (~1130) who observed: "We are like dwarfs standing [or sitting] upon the shoulders of giants, and so able to see more and see farther than the ancients."

Those clinging to the mythology of IPRs are clinging to vestiges of the old economy, one in decline. In It’s Alive: The Coming Convergence of Information, Biology and Business (2003), Christopher Meyer and Stan Davis describe the economic life-cycle as gestation, growth, maturity and decline.  In this final phase enterprises are unable to adapt to new ways of organizing work, they thrive for a time but the period of exuberant growth has ended. Industries have consolidated but profitability is a function of oligopoly power and organization skills rather than growth or innovation.

In their earlier book Blur: The Speed of Change in the Connected Economy (1998), Meyers and Davis highlight the power of connectivity, speed and the rising importance of intangibles characterizing these three as “the derivatives of time, space and mass.” 

The Creative Commons has been operational since 2001, thanks to Lawrence Lessig et al. Open-sourcing—that is, free access and redistribution of digital code, media and the like—has long been a silent partner of Internet growth. Engaging collaborative synergies (peer production, massively multiplayer online games (MMOG) and alternate-reality games (ARG) and ResearchGate) is at the heart of new production models, while prosuming (coined by futurist Alvin Toffler in 1980) and freeiums are fast becoming the business model of necessity.

The old economy—hinged together by antiquated rules—daily draws closer to its expiration date. The Internet has proven a worthy opponent in its first spar with those seeking to hold together the old money-power base. May openness and innovation live a long and prosperous life!

And just in case the new kids on the block decide to get cocky; be reminded:

“All comparative advantage is temporary.  Some advantages last longer than others, but all sources of advantages have a finite shelf-life.” (Beinhocker 2006, 329)

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Monday, January 16, 2012

…my special message to Romney

By kay.e.strong 

On January 6th Romney was overheard delivering this Special Message to Europe:

“No, not a single cent. Europe got into this trouble on its own, and has to get out of it on its own. Germany, France, Italy. They all have the resources to pay their debts. They can solve the crisis, invest and start to grow again, possibly through (creating) a real market economy. The United States has to take care of its own crisis, and will not give a single dollar for saving Europe.”

Seriously, if gigantic red flags are not bursting wildly in your head, then perhaps you’re suffering from the same degenerative memory-eating microbe as Romney.

Hello, Mitt…in what silver-spooned luxury resort spa were you bunkered during the fall-out from the great American-engineered subprime mortgage crisis? You don’t remember it? It went something like this---the US at its epicenter.

  • American dream legislation ups low-income home ownership
  • Housing speculation and ballooning housing stock
  • US housing bubble bursts
  • US interest rates rise; housing prices peak
  • Precipitating defaults and foreclosures; furthering drops in home values
  • Stock market falters
  • Banks freeze; Washington Mutual, Wachovia and Lehman Brothers go bankrupt
  • Consumers drained of “paper” wealth; consumer confidence tanks
  • Consumers repress spending urge; job blood-letting begins
  • Federal Reserve slashes interest rates to zero; injects liquidity into the financial system
  • Congress passes assorted rescue packages
  • Unemployment rate at 8.5% (BLS); unofficial estimate closer to 15%
  • US poverty rate above 16%
  • US debt ($15.2T) to GDP ratio is now a 100+%
  • Fed balance sheet swell to over $2T total assets

And here we are in 2012…government deeper in debt; consumers deleveraged of assets and jobs!

The good news: were not alone! By 2007 the tentacles of the American-born crisis had reached deep into the heart of Scandinavian country.  Iceland went bankrupt. International investors lost billions on their holdings of subprime mortgage derivatives. Foreign stock markets flagged. Credit tightened worldwide. Trade slowed, driving growth rates south. European governments pumped the stimulus lever. And European central banks coordinated effort with the US to stem the global contraction.

Does any of this sound familiar, Mitt? I appreciate history is not everyone’s strong suit.

But the mark of a true 21st century statesman is the ability to see the world as it is…in its full 360 degree panorama mode where local disturbances propagated outward, generating impacts at regional and global scales.  Global connectivity through our markets (financial, product, currency) has woven the livelihood of our communities together. Our well-being is highly contingent upon those over whom we have neither authority nor control.  

Europe is not your neighbor’s pregnant daughter…and she certainly did not get into this trouble on her own!

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Sunday, January 15, 2012

…social symbiosis

Bykay.e.strong

I have to be honest…I have long considered the political scene in this country tantamount to a Barnum & Bailey sideshow (despite having majored in political science)!

“Come one, come all! Witness the amazing ‘missing link’ blathering on about nothingness, the snake oil salesman switching pitches faster than an Indy 500 driver changes gears on a dry straight-away, the spineless and the mental midgets from all walks of life!  Come one, come all. And do be amazed!” 

But I recently stumbled across a candidate in touch with World 3.0…Elizabeth Warren, whose run for Romney’s US Senate seat in 1994 failed but is back on the November ballot in Massachusetts.  Warren brings to the table a fresh perspective, one involving the world as we experience it… complex, interconnected and adaptive.  In September as the OWS movement was gaining momentum, Warren astutely reframed the “greed is good” mythology into one of modern day truth: social symbiosis.

“There is nobody in this country who got rich on his own. Nobody. You built a factory out there, good for you. But, I want to be clear: you moved your goods to market on the roads the rest of us paid for. You hired workers the rest of us paid to educate. You were safe in your factory because of police forces and fire forces that the rest of us paid for. You didn’t have to worry that marauding bands would come and seize everything at your factory and hire someone to protect against this because of the work the rest of us did. Now look, you built a factory and it turned into something terrific or a great idea. God bless. Keep a big hunk of it. But part of the underlying social contract is you take a hunk of that and pay forward for the next kid who comes along.” [ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hOyDR2b71ag ]

In his 1975 book Sociobiology: the new synthesis, E.O. Wilson introduced social symbiosis as it related to the insect world, particularly, ants. By his definition, symbiosis includes all categories of close protracted interaction. When the symbiosis benefits one participating species while neither benefiting nor harming the other, it is referred to as social commensalism. Mixed flocks of birds foraging in the winter are an example of social commensalism. When both species benefit it is social mutualism. Aphids kept as “cattle” by ants exemplify social mutualism.  Social Parasitism occurs when one species benefits at the peril of another. (354) Wilson writes that “[i]n its consequences on population growth parasitism does not differ fundamentally from predation.” (354)

Old-man politics is social parasitism still pumping the mythological Horatio Alger message, still relying on backroom fat cats and still shape-shifting without a morsel of conscience, misconstruing Paul’s declaration of being “All things to all people…”

Elizabeth Warren is a glimmer of a new political generation…telling Donne’s truth: “No man is an island, entire of itself...” We are social beings. We live in a symbiotic relationship with one another. We create the society in which we live. By seeing the essence of our world as social symbiosis—individuals linked through mutually supportive networks, then we take our first step  in transforming it.

John Donne poem No man is an island speaks to the heart of social mutualism.

No man is an island entire of itself; every man
is a piece of the continent, a part of the main;
if a clod be washed away by the sea, Europe
is the less, as well as if a promontory were, as
well as a manor of thy friends or of thine
own were; any man's death diminishes me,
because I am involved in mankind.
And therefore never send to know for whom
the bell tolls; it tolls for thee.


Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Wednesday, January 4, 2012

At Last a Utilometer?

By Lewis Sage


Looks as if our colleagues in cognitive neuroscience are on the way to removing one of the most familiar limitations of microeconomics, our inability to measure satisfaction directly.  Writing in the Fall, 2011 issue of The Journal of Economic Perspectives, Ernst Fehr and Antonio Rangel review recent fMRI advances that may give researchers a “utilometer,” an instrument whose metric captures that elusive feeling of wellbeing.  Economists’ traditional approach to the problem has been to use the principle of revealed preference, the claim that rational people more-or-less infallibly select the most preferred option available.  There are a couple of problematic assumptions underlying that model – notably the premises of rationality and precise judgment – but it’s been the best approximation for a long time.  We’re a long way from abandoning the principle of revealed preference, but the underlying premises may yield to fruitful revision.
First, the issue of measuring utility directly.  It seems that my brain divides the task, using different areas to paint the “before” and “after” pictures, with my ventromedial prefrontal cortex acting as my personal calculator of expected utility and transcranial wire-tapping providing a read-out.  Preferences revealed in subjects’ willing to pay to receive a prospective prize (or to avoid a prospective punishment) are correlated with their levels of VPC neural activity.  And, supporting economists’ habit of treating costs avoided as benefits achieved, winning and not losing are apparently measured on the same scale and with the same neuroanatomical tool.   My experience of utility from actually consuming a good – as opposed to expected satisfaction – is measured elsewhere, in my orbitofrontal cortex and the nucleus accumbens.  And there is evidence of a functional connection between these apparatuses: experienced satisfaction appears to be inversely correlated with anticipated satisfaction.  Translation: I prefer happy surprises to disappointment.  Good to know.
Peeking into the brain also provides insight into the familiar – to economists at least – concept of indifference between alternatives.  Evidence in the form of activity in the dorsomedial prefrontal cortex and bilateral interparietal sulcus provides preliminary support for the “drift-diffusion” model of stochastic choice based on closeness of options.  Indifference curves, for those of us who care about such things, turn out to be thick and fuzzy.  Translation: the less difference between alternatives, the harder it is to choose consistently.  So much for the premise of precise rational decision-making.  Apparently, I don’t even know my own mind with any reliability.  Which means that I’m likely to make mistakes.  The good news, however, is that, if I pay enough attention, they are unlikely to be big mistakes.  Comforting.
So... we can measure utility directly, if only approximately, whether we're neuroscientists or ordinary humans.  And, as a bonus, I’m really pleased to learn how many internal calculators I’m able to coordinate without being aware of any of them.


Dr. Lewis C. Sage (AB Kenyon, PhD U. Maryland) likes intersections. Since 1991, he has taught Law and Economics, Mathematical Economics, and the Economics of Healthcare. A former Fulbright Fellow (Bulgaria 1995-6), he teaches an interdisciplinary Honors seminar, Enduring Questions, and is studying strategy in the NFL draft with faculty and students in Sport Management and Psychology. E-mail: lsage@bw.edu

Saturday, December 31, 2011

…get off the insanity treadmill

By kay.e.strong


We are on the verge of sleepwalking through yet another year—vaguely cognizant that our mental map of the world is sorely misaligned with reality, yet barely conscious enough to form a coherent question about how.

Albert Einstein offers an insight worth reflecting on.  He posited that the thinking we use to solve our problems is in reality the source of our problems. The Greenspan 2008 epiphany is an apt illustration. Appearing before a congressional panel investigating the evolving financial crisis, he admitted "a flaw" in his view of world markets, despite “very considerable evidence that it was working exceptionally well” for forty years or more. To his credit, though, Alan Greenspan is, perhaps, the only leader on record to acknowledge that his mental model of the world had fallen out of sync with reality.  Despite this shocking admission by such a highly revered economic-seer, decision-makers and politicians alike have insisted on clinging to out-moded thinking about how the economy operates in reality.

Daily the news pours out evidence indicting the very thinking used to solve our problems.

…deleveraged of assets, homelessness on the rise

…rebound recession worries imported from abroad; yet, $1.6 T. safely tucked away by US banking system

…military spending on autopilot, while investment in people—the true pillars of growth—stagnate

…tax breaks—a runaway train speeding to “Utopia” (Greek for no place), despite proof that higher top income tax rates produce far more jobs

Einstein is also quoted as having defined insanity: doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.  

2012 is an excellent time to get off the insanity treadmill and reboot our mental models to better align with reality—a reality steeped in uncertainty, complexity and in need of new leadership attuned to this new reality.

Consider Joshua Ramo’s book The Age of the Unthinkable: Why the New World Disorder Constantly Surprises Us and What we Can Do About it (2009).  He passionately describes the melt-downs in the global order arising from mismatched mental images and plans for action. When we don’t see the world as a system, we miss the indirect linkages that hold the power to cascade change through a system in response to a direct challenge. He offers his book as a guide to how we can save ourselves—a “decoder ring for the perplexities of our current world, for the dangerous magic that seems to be unspooling everywhere. And it is also, once you’ve understood it clearly, a way for anyone, from eight to eighty, to begin to see what this world means for you — and to see what you can do about it.” (8)

Consider Rebecca Costa’s book The Watchman’s Rattle: Thinking Our Way Out of Extinction (2010). She succinctly identifies the key of our current woes: “The primary cause of all threatening trends is the complexity of civilization itself, which can’t be understood and managed by the cognitive tools we have thus far choose to use. (xi) She argues that our cultural tendency is to focus on the symptoms which we can wrap our head around rather than the underlying problem tangled in a web of complexity. We grab quick-fix solutions for what appear the obvious symptoms but make ourselves more vulnerable to their dangerous consequences.  From Costa’s perspective the key to survival is revving up the way a culture ‘thinks’ to match the complexity rate of the external environment—the part of the environment over which we have no direct control, often little knowledge but holds the power to decimate our lives.

Consider Margaret Wheatley’s book Leadership and the New Science: Discovering Order in a Chaotic World (2006).  My chance encounter with this one sent my head spinning! Wheatley offers hope when she asserts that "[a] system can descend into chaos and unpredictability, yet within that state of chaos the system is held within boundaries that are well-ordered and predictable." (13) Every living system changes to preserve itself. To do so, however, requires that system maintain a clear sense of identity and freedom of choices, while self-organizing to a higher level of complexity better matched to its environment.  Everywhere, life self-organizes as networks of relationships, thereby, making relationships the “basic building blocks” of life.  

May tomorrow be the day you step off the insanity treadmill and challenge your own thinking about reality as it is—not as it once was.


Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Saturday, December 24, 2011

…living on the edge

By kay.e.strong


On the heels of the Census Bureau revelation that nearly half of all Americans are living in poverty or low incomes, comes a new report, America’s Youngest Outcasts 2010. No, it’s not a made for TV reality show—it is reality for 1.6 million American children (1 in 45).  In the finger-pointing game of yesteryear, your typical social conservatives would link the plight of a child to the irresponsible behavior of the parent.  Yup, you’ve heard ‘em all…the unwed teenage mother syndrome, propagation for [welfare benefits] profit, drug addicted parents, and the like. But the National Center on Family Homelessness sets the record straight on this one.

“Financial speculation sparks collapse of the housing market and financial institutions, a stock market crash, and the Great Recession. The numbers of homeless children increased by more than 448,000 from 2007 to 2010; 1.6 million (one in 45 children) are homeless in 2010—that is a 38% spike from 2007.”  < http://www.familyhomelessness.org/ >

To satiate the greed of the few—1.6 million children—more than 30,000 children each week—more than 4,400 each day are being sacrificed. Homeless, hungry and malnourished, declining physical health, emotional trauma, a lost sense of security and unstable educational opportunities follow these children where ever they go.  As the National Center on Family Homelessness concludes “[p]lanning and policy activities to support the growth and development of these vulnerable children remain limited. Sixteen states have done no planning related to child homelessness, and only seven states have extensive plans.”  Let’s add hopelessness to that list. Living on the edge, the nation’s most vulnerable are cheated of life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness long before reaching voting age!

In 1996 the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Act passed.  The Act was hailed as breakthrough legislation on welfare reform.  While signing the bill into law, Clinton declared that the act "gives us a chance we haven't had before to break the cycle of dependency … It gives structure, meaning and dignity to most of our lives."  It is time to enforce the same reform on the twenty-first century Welfare Queen, the nation’s financial sector. It’s time to demand that the Queen support the nation’s future, its children, in ways that “give structure, meaning and dignity” to their young lives.
 

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Thursday, December 22, 2011

...scanning for tomorrow

By kay.e.strong


I’m an avid scanner, a skill honed while attending the futures program at the U of Houston.  Scanning is not a duplication task but rather an exploratory one. One designed to provide clues about the potential shape of the more distant tomorrow.  In the spirit of sharing, I offer a glance into how our tomorrow is shaping up.

Launched in 2009 as a nonprofit organization by Shai Reshef, University of the People (UoPeople) is the world’s first tuition-free online academic institution dedicated to the global advancement and democratization of higher education. The high-quality low-cost global educational model embraces the worldwide presence of the Internet and dropping technology costs to bring university-level studies within reach of millions of people across the world. With the support of respected academics, humanitarians and other visionaries, the UoPeople student body represents a new wave in global education. <http://www.uopeople.org/ >

Can you image the impact of engaging the creative potential of 7 billion minds!

***********

Lumus is showing off a pair of light, wearable HD video glasses that will allow you to interact with the world via augmented reality. It is forecast that wearable displays will replace hand-held screens like iPads or laptops.  < http://techcrunch.com/2011/12/13/heads-up-lumus-shows-off-720p-see-through-video-glasses/ >

With data chips embedded in products, animals and surfaces, imagine information overload on steroids bombarding your eyeballs!

And if you can't afford the video glasses, no problem!  The cell phone hologram is on IBM’s list of the Next Five in Five years. Merging 3D technology into the cell phones will enable projection of life size holograms of friends talking and moving in real time on any surface.  < http://www.computerworld.com/s/article/920140/Holograms_on_cell_phones_coming_in_five_years_IBM_predicts >

If I send my hologram, do you think students will know the difference in my 8 AM class?

***********

The U.S. Defense Advanced Projects Research Agency (DARPA) plans to put 1,000 3-D printers (rapid fabrication devices) into high schools across the United States as a way to encourage American young people to go into engineering and particularly manufacturing.
The project is one of many investments that the agency will make over the next five years to help high schoolers build STEM skills. These investments are critical to grow an educated twenty-first century workforce, says DARPA director Regina Dugan. < http://www.wfs.org/content/futurist-update/futurist-update-2011-issues/november-2011-vol-12-no-11 >

The twenty-first century upgrade to shop class!  I hope they have a backup plan for containing projects gone wrong!

***********

Why not take a bad-news break as we wind down the year. Try some exploratory scanning of your own.  Follow up with the question “What if?” and consider the rich possibilities that tomorrow could bring. It's great calistetics for the mind and spirit.

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Friday, December 16, 2011

…identity crisis in America

By kay.e.strong


One of the great atrocities unleashed on the American mind is the eradication of the lines distinguishing good economics from bad politics.

In introductory courses I distinguish between the end goals of economics and politics. For economics the goal is to maximize the well-being of the majority at the expense of the minority; the opposite is true for politics. Yet the bandwidth for a well-moneyed politician overwhelms that of even the most accomplished economist.

Politicians package the protection of corporate America’s interest as a common good, that is, beneficial to all members of the community. Prostituting themselves to the fortunes of millionaires, politicians propagate Kochism dribble: 

1. America must be governed (politics) by the free-market forces (economics).

2. Paying taxes (economics) is tantamount to government extortion (politics).

3. Individuals (politics) have no responsibility to society (economics).

Let's sift out the economic truths.

First, economist Jeffery Sachs in his book The Price of Civilization (2011) clarifies that all great promoters of free-market forces acknowledge a role for government.

“…Adam Smith, John Maynard Keynes, Paul Samuelson, Friedrich Hayek, and Milton Friedman, were fully aware of the reality of public goods, environmental spillovers, and asymmetric information and therefore of the need for government to be deeply engaged in public education, road building, scientific discovery, environmental protection, financial regulation, and many other activities.  None ever denied a major role for government in a market system.  That’s true not only for Keynes and Samuelson, who are famous for their championship of mixed economy, but also Hayek and Friedman, who are known for their advocacy of unfettered markets.” (34)

Second, free-market forces are stellar at promoting efficient use of resources and growing income.

Financially, the US is the wealthiest nation on the planet earning 14.5 trillion dollars in 2010—a  slow year by some standards.  Yet, our national debt stands at 15+ trillion dollars. By one estimate, the national debt has increased an average of $3.93 billion per day since September 28, 2007! < http://www.brillig.com/debt_clock/ > Why? We can afford to pay for civilization right now rather than foisting it off onto future generations. According to the American Society of Civil Engineers' 2009 report card, we are in need of a 2.2 trillion dollars investment infusion to replace or repair our aging infrastructure including roads and bridges ($930 b.), public transit ($265 b.), drinking and waste water treatment ($255 b.),and schools ($160 b.). <http://www.infrastructurereportcard.org/> Our disinvestment is showing up in our declining ability to compete in a globalized market. 

Third, free-market forces are notoriously unfair.  Those holding a minor advantage at the start of the game end with a major wealth and income advantage.

Today’s headline read: Census shows 1 in 2 people are poor or low- income (15 Dec). That works out to 156, 392,664 million Americans—half the U.S. population!  Census data, according to the news release, depicts “a middle class that's shrinking as unemployment stays high and the government's safety net frays. The new numbers follow years of stagnating wages for the middle class that have hurt millions of workers and families.”

Blurring economics as politics is the deadly elixir that got us where we are today! Columbia University economist Jeffery Sachs argues “[o]nly markets and government operating as complementary pillars of the economy can produce the prosperity and fairness that we seek.” (179)

And paying for civilization is a choice, a choice of responsible governance, a choice that recognizes the truth of WAIT-T!

 

Kay Strong, Ph.D., Southern Illinois University, M.T., University of Houston, M.A., Ohio University; Associate Professor at Baldwin-Wallace College; Areas of expertise: international economics, contemporary social-economic issues, complexity and futures-based perspectives in economics. E-mail: kstrong@bw.edu

Friday, December 9, 2011

Whom Are We Kidding?

By Lewis Sage


Writing in the current issue (v. 90 no. 6) of Foreign Affairs, George Packer indicts the alliance of conservatives and big money that came together, “beginning in 1978 to begin a massive generation-long transfer of wealth to the richest Americans.”  The US Senate’s refusal to surtax millionaires to finance the extension of workers’ payroll tax-cut is the latest evidence of the success of that alliance.
The oft-heard Republican claim that a tax on the rich would stall the job-creating engine of small business is disingenuous.  Commenting for House Speaker John Boehner, Michael Steele characterized surtax as “a job-killing tax on small businesses” (quoted in The New York Times, 11/29/12).  The premise of his argument is that many small business owners choose to report business profits as personal income – a perfectly legal tax strategy – and that a tax on their income, which amounts to a tax on business profits, discourages those folks from hiring.  I get it that small business owners, like most people, aren’t in a big hurry to pay more taxes for no reason whatsoever, but there’s are good reasons for this increase: the fairness inherent in an intact social contract and a degree of enlightened self-interest in economic recovery.  And surtax is not a job-killer.  Here’s why.
Time for a little algebra.  Suppose that hiring a new employee would increase your profit by $1000 a year after taxes.  Is it worth it to you to hire that employee?  No?  Then you’re not really all that into squeezing for profit.  Your marginal tax rate could increase by two or three percent, and you wouldn't even notice.  But if you would hire that new worker to increase profits by $1000, then you're the sort of person who pays attention to detail and you’ll do whatever it takes to increase your disposable income.  In particular, if that new worker increased your after-tax profits by $980 (98% of $1000), you would still hire them.  Okay. Here’s the algebra.  Whatever it takes to increase pre-tax profits by $1000 automatically increases after-tax profits by $980.  Whatever increases pre-tax profit by $X automatically increases after-tax profit by 98% of $X.  There; that wasn’t so painful.
So here it is in a nutshell.  Surtaxing millionaire business owners reduces their disposable incomes.  But it does absolutely nothing to their profit-maximizing business decisions… nothing!



Dr. Lewis C. Sage (AB Kenyon, PhD U. Maryland) likes intersections. Since 1991, he has taught Law and Economics, Mathematical Economics, and the Economics of Healthcare. A former Fulbright Fellow (Bulgaria 1995-6), he teaches an interdisciplinary Honors seminar, Enduring Questions, and is studying strategy in the NFL draft with faculty and students in Sport Management and Psychology. E-mail: lsage@bw.edu

Baldwin Wallace University

My photo
This blog lives under the auspices of the Department of Economics whose mission has been to hold high the lantern beaming an "economic way of thinking" onto the world. Selfishness, rationality and equilibrium have been central to the teaching of an economic way of thinking rooted in the Renaissance. And, in this regard, the department has faithfully stayed the course. The intent of this blog, thinking out loud..., however, is to entertain exchanges which may challenge the centrality of economics as we teach it.